
Sacred Cow
A sacred cow is a firmly held belief that is rarely questioned and is largely exempt from criticism or opposition. However, legal rulings suggest that this common wisdom is, in fact, a practical myth — there is actually no legal duty to maximize profits in the management of a corporation. The idea can be traced in large part to the oversize effects of a single outdated and widely misunderstood ruling by the Michigan Supreme Court's 1919 decision in _Dodge vs. Ford Motor Co._, which was about the legal duty of a controlling majority shareholder with respect to a minority shareholder and not about maximizing shareholder value. A firm's beholden duty to maximize shareholder value is a good example of a sacred cow. Some examples of ideas that have been labeled sacred cows in finance include mutual funds, dividend investing, saving 15% of one's income for retirement, financial planning, and Morningstar's style box. For instance, whether or not universal healthcare should be provided free to all citizens may be a sacred cow to one group, but considered ridiculous to an opposing group.

More in Economy
What Is a Sacred Cow?
A sacred cow is a firmly held belief that is rarely questioned and is largely exempt from criticism or opposition. As such, tenets that are considered sacred cows are often held on to, even in the face of contradictory evidence.



Understanding Sacred Cows
Sacred cows are often widely held, but may also be a matter of opinion. A sacred cow may be considered based on time-tested wisdom. Ideas labeled as sacred cows can also reflect one's ideology. While some may apply the label of sacred cow to the "free market" or to "capitalist corporations", others put the "minimum wage" or "government programs" into this category.
In investing and elsewhere, the term is often used to dismiss any idea that an author is arguing against. Some examples of ideas that have been labeled sacred cows in finance include mutual funds, dividend investing, saving 15% of one's income for retirement, financial planning, and Morningstar's style box.
Ideas that are labeled sacred cows may also be referred to as "myths" by some, especially when a claim is contested. For instance, whether or not universal healthcare should be provided free to all citizens may be a sacred cow to one group, but considered ridiculous to an opposing group.
The term "sacred cow" is a reference to Hinduism, which reveres the cow as a holy animal.
Debunking a Sacred Cow? Shareholder Value Maximization
A firm's beholden duty to maximize shareholder value is a good example of a sacred cow. It is commonly understood that corporate directors and management have a duty to maximize shareholder value, especially for publicly traded companies. However, legal rulings suggest that this common wisdom is, in fact, a practical myth — there is actually no legal duty to maximize profits in the management of a corporation.
The idea can be traced in large part to the oversize effects of a single outdated and widely misunderstood ruling by the Michigan Supreme Court's 1919 decision in Dodge vs. Ford Motor Co., which was about the legal duty of a controlling majority shareholder with respect to a minority shareholder and not about maximizing shareholder value. Legal and organizational scholars such as Lynn Stout and Jean-Philippe Robé have elaborated on this myth at length. They conclude that shareholder maximization is not only a misinterpretation of a legal mandate but also confounds the purpose of a firm's goals vis-à-vis its broader set of stakeholders. In fact, they argue more strongly that putting shareholders; interest first harms investors, corporations, and the public.
While these papers were published in the early 2010s, a decade later the mantra of maximizing shareholder value remains a firmly held belief by many individuals and firm management. This makes it a sacred cow that is difficult to kill off.
Related terms:
Closely Held Corporation
A closely held corporation is a firm with a limited number of shareholders. Discover the pros and cons of closely held versus public corporations. read more
Economics : Overview, Types, & Indicators
Economics is a branch of social science focused on the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. read more
Fiduciary
A fiduciary is a person or organization that acts on behalf of a person or persons and is legally bound to act solely in their best interests. read more
Finance
Finance is the study and management of money, investments, and other financial instruments. Learn about the basics of public, corporate, and personal finance. read more
Inflation
Inflation is a decrease in the purchasing power of money, reflected in a general increase in the prices of goods and services in an economy. read more
John Maynard Keynes
John Maynard Keynes is one of the founding fathers of modern-day macroeconomic theories. Learn how Keynesian economics impacts spending and taxes. read more
Shareholder Value
Shareholder value is what is delivered to equity owners of a corporation because of management's ability to increase earnings, dividends, and share prices. read more
Socialism : History, Theory, & Analysis
Socialism is an economic and political system based on public or collective ownership of the means of production that emphasizes economic equality. read more